Saving and investing for the future is becoming increasingly popular in the UK as individuals and families seek financial security. One of the most commonly used tools for this is Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs), and there are two main types: investment ISAs and savings ISAs. Both provide tax-free benefits, which can be attractive to those wanting to save or invest their hard-earned money. However, you must understand their differences before deciding which suits you.
Table of Contents
Interest rates
The first main difference between an investment ISA and a savings ISA is the interest rate. A savings ISA generally offers a higher interest rate, meaning the money it saves will accrue more quickly than in an investment ISA. It makes them ideal for those who want to save up for something specific such as a holiday or a house deposit. However, this also means that you will likely be locked into the same bank and unable to move your money around should better rates become available elsewhere.
In contrast, an investment ISA usually has variable interest rates, which can change over time depending on market conditions and other factors. This flexibility can be attractive to those who want to take advantage of potential opportunities, but it also means that their money is exposed to more risk.
Accessibility
Another difference between an investment ISA and a savings ISA is accessibility. Since a savings ISA is built around the idea of longer-term saving goals, you will generally find that there are restrictions on how much you can withdraw each year and when you can do so. It makes them less suitable for those needing access to their money more quickly, such as if they suddenly lose their job or have an unexpected expense come up.
In contrast, an investment ISA is designed flexibly and typically allows regular deposits and withdrawals throughout the year. It makes them more suitable for those who need to access their money quickly or those who want the freedom to move their money around if better rates become available.
Risk
The risk associated with each type is the third significant difference between an investment ISA and a savings ISA. A savings ISA is generally considered the safer option because it’s less exposed to market fluctuations that could adversely affect your returns. Therefore, although you will still experience some interest rate changes, they are usually relatively modest and unlikely to cause significant financial losses.
In contrast, an investment ISA carries more significant risks due to its exposure to stock markets and other investment opportunities. It can be beneficial if the markets perform well, as it could yield more significant returns, but it also means that an investor is more likely to experience losses should the markets turn sour.
Tax treatment
Another difference between an investment ISA and a savings ISA is the tax implications. Both ISAs are tax-free, so HMRC will not tax any interest earned. However, there are differences in how the two types of ISAs are treated for Capital Gains Tax (CGT).
With a savings ISA, any profits from investments inside it are exempt from CGT. Therefore, you won’t have to pay extra tax when withdrawing money from your ISA account, provided it has been held within the ISA wrapper for at least 12 months.
In contrast, investment ISAs are subject to CGT on any profits from investments held within them. Therefore, if you gain when withdrawing money, the amount above the annual CGT allowance will be taxed at either 18% or 28%, depending on your tax bracket.
Potential returns
There is a difference between an investment ISA and a savings ISA regarding potential returns. As mentioned, a savings ISA usually offers higher interest rates than an investment ISA due to its lower risk profile. Therefore, it’s ideal for those looking for steady growth over time without taking too much risk.
In contrast, an investment ISA is exposed to stock markets and other investment opportunities, which means that potential returns are often much higher. However, it should be noted that this also means a greater risk of losses should the markets turn sour. It’s essential to weigh your options carefully before deciding which ISA suits you and your circumstances.
